Category: History

Medical constructions of long-term exhaustion, past and present

Abstract:

Culture and history affect the ways in which medical knowledge is shaped, sustained and changed. The less knowledge we have, the larger the space for the cultural imprint becomes. Based on these assumptions, we ask: how have medical constructions of long-term exhaustion changed over time, and how are changing constructions related to societal change? To discuss these questions we conducted a comparative study of medical texts from two historical periods: 1860-1930 and 1970-2013.

Our data are limited to two diagnoses: neurasthenia and encephalomyelitis. After comparing the two periods by identifying diverging and converging aspects, we interpreted observed continuities and interruptions in relation to historical developments. We found that in the medical literature, long-term exhaustion became transformed from a somatic ailment bred by modern civilisation to a self-inflicted psychiatric ailment. At the same time, it changed from being a male-connoted high-status condition to a female-connoted low-status condition. We interpret these changes as contingent upon culturally available modes of interpretations. Medical knowledge thereby becomes infused with cultural norms and values which give them a distinct cultural bias. The historical controversies surrounding this medically contested condition neatly display the socially contingent factors that govern the social construction of medical knowledge.

© 2015 The Authors. Sociology of Health & Illness published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of Foundation for SHIL.

 

Source: Lian OS, Bondevik H. Medical constructions of long-term exhaustion, past and present. Sociol Health Illn. 2015 Jul;37(6):920-35. doi: 10.1111/1467-9566.12249. Epub 2015 Apr 24. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25912053

 

History of chronic fatigue syndrome

Abstract:

Chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) is not a new disease. Similar morbidities have been known as different names since past several centuries. For example, neurasthenia, epidemic neuromyasthenia, myalgic encephalomyelitis, Akureyri disease, Royal Free disease, chronic EBV disease, post-viral fatigue syndrome etc. Much of the recent interest in CFS was generated by incidence of infection-like outbreak at Lake Tahoe in Nevada. The Center for Disease Control (USA) realized that correlation was poor between those patients who had virologic evidence of EBV infection and those who had the symptoms of chronic fatigue. This is a review of the history of CFS. (1) Historical perspectives in chronic fatigue cases in past old period, (2) Post-viral infectious fatigue and chronic fatigue (myalgic encephalomyelitis), (3) Recent trend of CFS studies and its clinical similar situation. Finally, I would like to state that we intend to draw up a new diagnostic guideline for CFS in Japan.

 

Source: Hashimoto N. History of chronic fatigue syndrome. Nihon Rinsho. 2007 Jun;65(6):975-82. [Article in Japanese] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17561685

 

Mark Twain and his family’s health: Livy Clemens’ neurasthenia in the gilded age and chronic fatigue syndrome of today

Abstract:

Our purpose is to compare and contrast the 19th century diagnosis and disease neurasthenia with the contemporary illness known as Chronic Fatigue Syndrome. The health of Mark Twain’s wife, Olivia (Livy) Clemens, will then be discussed and evaluated with respect to these two medical conditions.

 

Source: Arcari R, Crombie HD. Mark Twain and his family’s health: Livy Clemens’ neurasthenia in the gilded age and chronic fatigue syndrome of today. Conn Med. 2003 May;67(5):293-6. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12802844

 

On the history of the concept neurasthenia and its modern variants chronic-fatigue-syndrome, fibromyalgia and multiple chemical sensitivities

Abstract:

This article deals with the history of the terminological and nosological development of the concept neurasthenia introduced in 1869 by George Miller Beard and in particular with its reappearance in western medicine in the 1980 s. Beginning with its predecessors in antiquity and continuing with hypochondria, which became a fashionable disease in the 18 th century, the concept neurasthenia reached a high point and world-wide medical acceptance at the end of the 19 th/beginning of the 20 th century. However, between the 1930 s and 1960 s it declined in popularity and gradually disappeared until finally it only had a rudimentary nosological role in the term “pseudoneurasthenia”. In the countries of the Far East, on the contrary, the concept of neurasthenia has been in continual use since its importation in the first decades of the last century. In the 1980 s, when an interest in the symptoms of chronic fatigue was reawakened in western medicine, the concept neurasthenia reappeared, this time to define the particular form of a neurotic disorder.

Parallel to these developments increasing importance was attached to clinical descriptions of illnesses which on account of their similarity to the symptoms of neurasthenia could be termed modern variants of the concept neurasthenia. These are “Chronic-Fatigue-Syndrome”, “Fibromyalgia” and “Multiple Chemical Sensitivities” which have more or less adopted the organic inheritance of Beard’s former concept of neurasthenia, despite the fact that so far the question of organicity could not be decisively answered in a single case. In order to clarify possible influences on the development of the concept neurasthenia and its variants, the theories and ideas of E. Shorter, medical historian at the University of Toronto, are discussed in the final part of the article, whereby the particular cultural background in each case has a decisive influence on the manifestation of the psychosomatic symptoms.

 

Source: Schäfer ML. On the history of the concept neurasthenia and its modern variants chronic-fatigue-syndrome, fibromyalgia and multiple chemical sensitivities. Fortschr Neurol Psychiatr. 2002 Nov;70(11):570-82. [Article in German] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12410427

 

Feminist perspectives on the social construction of chronic fatigue syndrome

Abstract:

We contrast Western medical views of chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) etiology, diagnosis, and treatment with views maintained by a predominantly female CFS population. We argue that the failure of Western medicine to demonstrate a viral etiology for CFS led to a paradigmatic shift in research perspectives, which then embraced psychiatric and sociocultural explanations for CFS. As a result, CFS was delegitimized as a biomedical phenomenon within medical, academic, governmental, and public arenas.

We compare alternative social constructions of CFS with issues pertaining to multiple sclerosis (MS), an illness that similarly predominates among women. Patient perspectives suggest that the history of medical attitudes toward CFS may eventually parallel the transformations that occurred in relation to MS. In particular, the discovery of biological markers for CFS may lay to rest the categorization of CFS as largely within the psychiatric realm.

 

Source: Richman JA, Jason LA, Taylor RR, Jahn SC. Feminist perspectives on the social construction of chronic fatigue syndrome. Health Care Women Int. 2000 Apr-May;21(3):173-85. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11111464

 

Chronic fatigue syndrome. CDC struggles to recover from debacle over earmark

Comment on: Misallocation of CDC funds. [Science. 2000]

 

(This article in Science covers the misallocation of several million dollars intended for research into ME/CFS.)

“In the wake of the government inquiry, CDC has drawn up a “reinvigoration plan” to understand the disease. The new strategy, to be finalized in February after a series of hearings, includes a nationwide study of the prevalence of CFS and efforts to increase awareness of the disease.”

You can read the full article here: http://www.ganino.com/games/Science/science%20magazine%201999-2000/root/data/Science%201999-2000/pdf/2000_v287_n5450/p5450_0022.pdf

 

Source: Enserink M. Chronic fatigue syndrome. CDC struggles to recover from debacle over earmark. Science. 2000 Jan 7;287(5450):22-3. http://www.ganino.com/games/Science/science%20magazine%201999-2000/root/data/Science%201999-2000/pdf/2000_v287_n5450/p5450_0022.pdf

Case of chronic fatigue syndrome after Crimean war and Indian mutiny

Chronic fatigue syndrome was first proposed as a diagnostic label in 1988 to classify a disorder characterised by severe fatigue and exhaustion after minimal physical and mental effort accompanied by other unexplained somatic symptoms.1 It was introduced partly as an acceptable clinical alternative to the term myalgic encephalomyelitis, which described a similar presentation and had been coined in 1956 in the aftermath of an outbreak of illness among the nursing and medical staff of the Royal Free Hospital.2 The condition was widely assumed to be a new addition to the medical scene. In the popular press, and occasionally in the professional publications, attempts have been made to explain chronic fatigue syndrome as a product of the unwelcome features of modern life, such as pollution, stress, working practices, and new infections.

You can read the full article here: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1127098/

 

Source: Jones E, Wessely S. Case of chronic fatigue syndrome after Crimean war and Indian mutiny. BMJ. 1999 Dec 18-25;319(7225):1645-7. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1127098/ (Full article)

Neurasthenia, yesterday and today

Abstract:

Neurasthenia was described and explained in very mechanistic terms, at the end of the 19th century, by G.M. Beard to account for physical and mental exhaustion and for varied somatic troubles imputed to failure of too much solicited nervous resources. This concept was then universally adopted and gave rise to diverse interpretations, among which was the Freud’s one. Later, in Occident, came a deterioration, the diagnostic of neurasthenia giving way to those of anxious or affective disorders. In the same time, at least for ideological and cultural reasons, the concept remained lively in Russia and in Asia. During the last decade the western psychiatry has been led to accept that there are clinical situations focussed on fatigue and fatigability, even if it coined for them new terminologies (post-infectious fatigue, chronic fatigue syndrome, etc.) and while DSMs keep on ignoring neurasthenia, the ICD 10 gives it an important place.

 

Source: Pichot P. Neurasthenia, yesterday and today. Encephale. 1994 Nov;20 Spec No 3:545-9.[Article in French] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/7843049

 

The chronic fatigue syndrome: what do we know?

Abnormally persistent or recurrent fatigue is a feature of many disorders. Recently, particular attention has been devoted to people whose life is dominated by protracted and disabling fatigue. Such cases are now usually categorised as the chronic fatigue syndrome, the postviral fatigue syndrome, or myalgic encephalomyelitis. Two recent publications bring together current ideas on the topic.

The historical background is important. Although the chronic fatigue syndrome has been advanced as a malaise of the latter part of this century, such cases are not a new phenomenon: they were particularly common during the latter part of the last century. The New York physician George Beard applied the label “neurasthenia” to them although the term was more widely used. After becoming an exceedingly common diagnosis it waned at the time of the first world war.

This first wave in the history of chronic fatigue was followed by a second wave, which can be dated to 1934. Nevertheless, cases of chronic fatigue did not simply disappear in the intervening period. The “effort syndrome” had a considerable vogue at that time. “Fibrositis,” a term introduced by Sir William Gowers in 1894 to designate the occurrence of diffuse muscle aching and pain without detectable explanation, evolved into “fibromyalgia.” This currently popular diagnosis has many overlapping features with the chronic fatigue syndrome, as did the effort syndrome.

You can read the rest of this article here: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1677985/pdf/bmj00024-0007.pdf

 

Comment in:

Functional hypoglycaemia postulated as cause of chronic fatigue syndrome. [BMJ. 1993]

Chronic fatigue syndrome. [BMJ. 1993]

 

Source: Thomas PK. The chronic fatigue syndrome: what do we know? BMJ. 1993 Jun 12;306(6892):1557-8. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1677985/

 

Chronic fatigue in historical perspective

Abstract:

Chronic fatigue as a presenting complaint, in the absence of other evident organic illness, was seldom reported historically before the second half of the 19th century. Its first eruption was the so-called ‘bed cases’ or ‘sofa cases’ among middle-class females in the period from 1860 to about 1910. ‘Neurasthenia’ does not necessarily represent an early forerunner of chronic fatigue.

Many patients receiving that diagnosis did not complain of fatigue. Others with functional fatigue did not receive the diagnosis ‘neurasthenia’. Both medical-anecdotal and quantitative sources make it clear that by the time of the First World War, chronic fatigue was a common complaint in Europe and North America.

Medical concepts of chronic fatigue since the 1930s have run along four separate lines: (1) ‘postinfectious neuromyasthenia’, going back to an atypical ‘poliomyelitis’ epidemic in 1934; (2) ‘chronic Epstein-Barr virus’ infection, an illness attribution that increased in frequency after the discovery in 1968 that this virus caused mononucleosis; (3) ‘myalgic encephalomyelitis’, dating from an epidemic at the Royal Free Hospital in London in 1955; and (4) ‘fibrositis’, or ‘fibromyalgia’, used as a rheumatological description since the turn of the century. Recently, these four separate paths have tended to converge into the diagnosis of ‘chronic fatigue syndrome’.

 

Source: Shorter E. Chronic fatigue in historical perspective. Ciba Found Symp. 1993;173:6-16; discussion 16-22. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/8491107