I was surprised that CMAJ published the letter from Drs. Gerald H. Ross and Jean A. Monro (Can Med Assoc J 1989; 140: 361) supporting such a vague, descriptive and unscientific term as “chronic fatigue syndrome”. As a practising psychiatrist I have attempted to emphasize that there are also primary psychologic causes of chronic fatigue such as depression and panic disorder (ibid: 361, 364); thus, it is more prudent to consider the relative causes of chronic fatigue than to create a “syndrome” that imposes a diagnostic life sentence of an incurable disease.
That a minuscule percentage of cases of chronic fatigue are due to chronic mononucleosis, other chronic infections and chemical sensitivity is not disputed. What is disputed is the number so diagnosed, particularly now that panic disorder – a primarily psychologic condition that causes chronic fatigue but is more amenable to treatment (antidepressant medication and dynamic insight-oriented psychotherapy) – appears to be reaching epidemic proportions. (1) Therefore, at the risk of considerable ideologic unpopularity, it would seem, I must repeat: “Primum non nocere.”
The statement by Ross and Monro that magnesium deficiency is associated with chemical sensitivity means just that and only that.
Ross and Monro’s six references are not definitive enough, the possible exception being the article of Tosato and colleagues (2) if – and only if – the chronic infectious mononucleosis referred to in the title was confirmed by serologic evidence of an acute attack. (3)
Ross and Monro display psychologic “sympathy” with “empathy” and quote me as referring to the term “psychosomatic” when I used the term “psychologic”.
“Syndromes” like “chronic fatigue syndrome” lessen the burden of introspection. In reverence to the “father” of nosology, Thomas Sydenham, and the “father” of psychiatry, Sigmund Freud, I must state, as a traditionally oriented psychiatrist, that it is nontherapeutic to condone self-defeating behaviour.
~Ray Holland, MD, FRCPC Box 458 Port Colborne, Ont.
References
1. Introduction. In Summary Proceedings of “Panic Disorder – Relative Merits of Pharmacotherapy and Psychotherapy” (satellite symposium of 1988 American Psychiatric Association annual meeting), Medical Group, Mississauga, Ont, 1988
2. Tosato G, Straus SE, Werner H et al: Characteristic T cell dysfunction in patients with chronic active EpsteinBarr virus infection (chronic infectious mononucleosis). J Immunol 1985; 134:3082-3088
3. Evans AS: A virus for all seasons.Buffalo Phys Biomed Sci 1988; 22 (2):14-15
Source: R Holland. Chronic fatigue syndrome. CMAJ. 1989 May 1; 140(9): 1016. PMCID: PMC1268972
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1268972/pdf/cmaj00190-0022b.pdf